Solutions for the Resource Planning Process in Line and Matrix Organisations (Practical Tips)

Which resource planning process do you need to ensure that the allocation of resources to projects works efficiently? What requirements does the process have to meet?

This article will outline the specific requirements matrix and line organisations place on the resource management process and how to define the right planning cycle that suits your form of organisation. You will learn more about the following topics:

• Challenges for the coordination process between project and line managers
• The solution: a suitable planning cycle
• The resource planning process in the line organisation
• The resource planning process in the matrix organisation
• Conclusion – Resource planning process

Let us begin!

Note: By tactical resource planning, we mean the coordination between project and line managers. This is dependent on the company’s form of organisation (matrix or line). The goal is to meet the project resource requirements by providing the necessary skills in a timely manner using line staff. This tends to be the team leaders’ responsibility.

What is Resource Planning in Project Management?

Definition: Resource planning in project management – aka resource management – is a key element of project management. It ensures that a project has access to the necessary resources (staff, facilities, etc.) at all times. This form of planning is very closely related to the development of schedules and budgets.

Resource planning is an important part of project management because:

• Resource management in project management helps a company reach its targets by focusing on optimisation and efficiency.
• The goal of every company is to achieve its objectives with as little effort as possible.
• Knowing what you need for the project to be successful lets you plan effectively and make economic use of the available resources. Larger companies often have a resource manager specifically for this purpose. This person relieves project managers of tasks such as organising the necessary resources for already planned projects from the team leaders involved.

What is the resource planning process?

Resource planning process refers to the workflow used for resource management and includes the process cycle, the arrangements for coordination between project and line managers and the use of tools for this purpose.

Challenges for the Coordination Process between Project and Line Managers

Project managers need the resource commitments from line managers as fast as possible because they need these commitments to plan their projects. Naturally, these commitments should still be truly reliable. How can this be achieved?

Given these constraints, the challenges for team leaders are as follows:

• Multiple project managers will send repeated requests to the same team leaders at different times
• This hinders team leaders from having a stable basis for their decisions
• Yesterday’s carefully coordinated plans may be obsolete today due to a new incoming request
• Team members are often assigned responsibilities outside of projects. This affects productivity in the projects.

The Solution: A Suitable Planning Cycle

The key to success in the resource planning process is to agree on a planning cycle. This can greatly help facilitate the resource planning process.

The length and duration of the cycle should be aligned with the lifespan of projects at your company. The organisational effort for planning and coordination needs to remain within reasonable limits over the long term.

Here is what matters:

• The longer the cycle, the more stable the system
• Too long also means too rigid
• Cycles between one and four weeks are customary and useful

We recommend starting with a monthly cycle. This will ensure acceptance without overwhelming the organisation. Only shorten the cycle once the system works and if the dynamics require it.

Our tip: Start with a monthly planning cycle. This will ensure acceptance without overwhelming the organisation. Shorten the cycle to 2-3 weeks once you know the system works and if the dynamics require it.

What to Consider for the Resource Planning Process

Get everyone involved to agree that PM resource plans for the current and the upcoming cycle can only be changed under exceptional circumstances. The use of resources should only be rescheduled for subsequent cycles.

This will save the company a lot of coordination effort because you will not have to deal with constant changes. Instead, rescheduling only happens at fixed intervals.

Another interesting read: Resource Management in Project Management

This approach requires all the participants to work harder at coordination. Ad-hoc changes only happen as a last resort. The implementation efficiency will be promoted because all staff members can work without interference for a longer period of time.

The figure below shows this type of process cycle at the levels of the roles involved.

Here is a practical example (see graphic above):

1. First, the team members must submit their time tracking reports by Friday.
2. The project managers must accept these by Monday night and reschedule the resulting remaining effort.
3. This may result in resource conflicts that only become apparent on Tuesday after all project managers have updated their plans (red square).
4. The team leaders have until Tuesday night or Wednesday (red circle) to resolve any conflicts. It is essential that the priorities are aligned with the strategy. Remember that those involved need to understand the strategy so that it can be considered here.
5. Finally – depending on the PMO (Project Management Office) functions – there will be a meeting with a steering group / top management in which the decisions are taken on all remaining issues arising from conflicts.

According to our PMO Survey, more than 50% of the PMOs questioned are already involved in “Resource allocation and conflict resolution” or are planning to establish this PMO function in the near future, see figure below. Resource management is also among the PMO responsibilities the respondents desire to expand in the future.

Our tip: Get everyone involved to agree that project resource management for the current and the upcoming cycles can be changed solely under exceptional circumstances. The use of resources can only be rescheduled for subsequent cycles.

Below, you will find out how the process of resource planning differs between line and matrix organisations.

The Resource Planning Process in the Line Organisation

In the line organisation, the negotiations are not about people but rather the deadlines for deliverables. The project managers plan which deliverables they need by what date. They forward these requirements to the team leaders.

The detailed planning is done by line managers. Project managers are not involved in resource planning at the level of individual staff members.

Project managers in the line organisation are mainly involved in coordinating the scheduling of projects and sub-projects or work packages. Resource coordination takes place within line departments / teams. The team leader is responsible for this.

In this environment, stable process cycles and traditional PM tools enable multiple projects to be managed transparently and can produce very good results. As an add-on for Microsoft Project Server, TPG ProjectLink is a tried-and-tested tool for line-level resource planning.

In a line organisation, team leaders can also use PM tools. These help them create detailed plans involving factors such as tasks and times (including absences) for their team as shown in the figure below.

In addition to project tasks, it is also possible to manage the team’s operations using the project plan. This means that the team leader only has to maintain one plan because it also includes all the team’s tasks:

• Project-related tasks
• Absences
• General operations
• Individual operations

The Coordination Process in the Line Organisation

The coordination process in a line organisation looks roughly like this:

1. Project managers plan approximate work packages – without the details or resources but with the planned efforts / budgets.
2. Project managers forward their rough plans / milestones to the team leaders.
3. Team leaders integrate these rough plans / milestones into their own plans.
4. Team leaders break down the work packages into individual tasks in their own planning. Next, they assign these tasks either to people in their own team or to external resources as well.
5. The team leaders’ planning can be compared with the the project managers’ at work package level regarding scheduling and efforts (see yellow bar on the left in the figure above).
6. Variances are visible on both sides. Project manager and team leader must discuss these variances to coordinate and eliminate them.

It is vital that project manager and team leader each use their own planning. In a separate step, the two plans are compared with each other.

Our tip: Make sure that the people in these roles are not able to change each other’s data! Protecting the autonomy of each person’s data enables project managers and team leaders to plan independently. Nonetheless, there should be a technical link between the team leader’s and the project manager’s plans to enable the sharing of data. This can be used to coordinate the use of resources.

The Resource Planning Process in the Matrix Organisation

The matrix organisation is a different thing altogether. Traditionally, project managers plan their projects with detailed tasks. They then assign these tasks to people or skills (generic resources).

The team leaders of the respective teams are the ones who decide which people are committed to the projects and to what extent. The team leaders must consider all the requests from different project managers, as well as absences and operations, to explore the possible commitments.

However, it usually makes little sense to make these commitments at the individual task level. As a rule, team leaders do not need to know which exact tasks have been assigned to their team members. They are more concerned with which team member is working on what projects – and when. For this, it is enough to have the project managers coordinate this at the project level.

Considering resource planning implementation? Here is how to do it fast and well.

Team leaders in a matrix organisation have the undesirable task of handling commitments of the required resources for different projects.

In most cases, traditional project management tools are inadequate for handling this. Why is this? Because the team leaders’ commitments are not maintained as an individual data pool. They are normally only marked with the status of the project or task.

The inherent problem: Postponements can occur in a project. If this happens, the staff commitments (which are only assigned a status) are simply postponed along with the tasks. However, team leaders only commit staff resources for designated periods of time.

This is logical because these same resources also need to work on other projects. For this reason, postponements usually result in resource conflicts, which spark new discussions (and require additional coordination).

For the coordination, project manager and team leader need to maintain their own planning data at the project level. These plans must be compared (see figure below).

If there is only the project managers’ plan, the team leaders are completely “at the project managers’ mercy”, at least in terms of the data. They can suggest ways to resolve the conflicts, but this will not change the project managers’ plans.

Neither can they negotiate with all project managers at once.

To be able to make commitments to the projects, team leaders need to first plan the absences and operations. They can only determine the real availability of a team member for the project on this basis.

Our tip: A resource management tool created especially for team leaders and supporting all requirements for successful resource coordination between project and line management in the matrix organisation is the optimal support for this case.

The Coordination Process in the Matrix Organisation

This is what the project resource management process in the matrix organisation looks like:

1. Project managers plan their projects in detail at task level.
2. Project managers assign either people or skills to the tasks.
3. Project managers request the required resources from the respective team leaders.
4. Team leaders determine the project availability of their team members from capacity minus absences and operations.
5. Team leaders analyse the resource requests from the different projects. They commit their team members for available periods of time.
6. The project managers incorporate these commitments (as time frames) at project level. Within these time frames, the project managers have flexibility in planning the tasks.
7. By comparing both roles’ planning, variances become visible. This provides a good basis for direct discussions to coordinate the efforts.

Our tip: Ensure team leaders in a matrix organisation have their own planning in which they also manage absences and operations. This enables an accurate evaluation of the availability and gives project managers the confidence to rely on the resource commitments.

Conclusion – Resource Planning Process

This article has described the resource planning process in project management. It has also shown how the processes are shaped by the organisational structure. You are now familiar with the coordination processes for line and matrix organisations.

For both forms of organisational structure, make sure that you establish adequate process cycles. Your team leaders cannot respond to resource requests for the coming week several times a day. You need to gather requests for the cycle after next, as well as the subsequent cycles, over the period of the current cycle. Responses to the requests are only required by the due date.

Ensure that the commitments for the current cycle remain as stable as possible. Changes should only be permitted under exceptional circumstances. This approach makes resource coordination reliable for all involved.

Our final tips:

Get to know the individually adaptable “PPM Paradise” – the optimal environment for your enterprise-wide project, program, portfolio and resource management (PPM). Download the free eBook “The PPM Paradise” now (just click, no form).

And sign up for our bi-weekly blog newsletter with information on more hands-on articles, eBooks, etc. to improve your project management maturity level.

Have you been involved in establishing a resource planning process? Do you agree on the importance of stable process cycles? Please leave a comment below.

print this article